Toshio and Kiyoshi shouldn't be responsible for their parent's debt because it is not their mistakes to pay for, and they're losing something so important; their youth. Toshio and Kiyoshi were I believe 14 when they started working for the plantation and their youth is something they can never get back. It's their father's mistakes that they're working for which is not teaching them to pay for their own mistakes. Too much responsibility for someone too young can be overwhelming and a loss of hopefulness. I understand that these ways are due to japanese culture's traditions and to them it's the only way they are living just to survive in poverty. They are a collectivists and to them it would be completely bizarre for the system to be any different than the way it is, but the way it is set up is completely unreasonable.
A lot of people look back and remember a time in their childhood being the most fun time of their lives, when they could just play and laugh and not worry about a thing. Children are fearless they laugh really loud, cry really hard, scream really loud and love a lot. Your childhood is something you can never get back and living with a family like his who has strong beliefs about how they have to act and little hope constraints the joyfulness of being a child. Your teenage years are important as well, you become aware of the way you look and who you are, you are becoming a little man or women. You make friends that mean the world to you and build memories together that last a lifetime. Having all of those good times taken from you and filled with stress and sadness is unfair. Your youth is something that you can never get back and if you do not act like a child while your a child you will always look back and regret things you missed out on.
It doesn't seem logical to me for the children to have to pay for their parent's mistakes. It seems like ineffective parenting, role modeling, and even morals. If japanese father's make mistakes and they're making their families pay for them then their modeling to their children not to pay for your own mistakes. Their father's are not taking responsibility for their own actions, instead their depending on their family to save them. It's not fair for the children and it's morally wrong for the parents. Why should the children have so much responsibility when their parents aren't taking responsibility for their own actions. I'm sure a lot of it has to do with living in poverty but it's shocking because parents should want what's best for their children and I would think that at least their mother would have been sensitive to their emotions. It wasn't like Toshio was complaining about taking the garbage out, or washing the dishes, but he was complaining about almost killing himself from working so hard. The sad thing is, Toshio's mother thought it was unreasonable for him to be complaining. At this point, his health could be fairly at risk and she is disappointed in him for it. Their father is the one that made the decisions to get them to where they were and so he should be the one to save his family and not depend on his young boys to do it for him.
It's unhealthy for someone so young to have that much responsibility. They are children and they already have to worry about all the stressors that are too hard for even an adult to worry about when in poverty. It's as if one day Toshio and Kiyoshi are happy they don't have a care in the world, and the next day it is up to them whether or not their family survives. It causes them to think less of themselves, and lose hope in life. They cannot be anything they want to be, they have to be the families dependent. Toshio and Kiyoshi do not get to experience what they're passionate about. They do not get to join in on sports and organized institutions that others with money get to. It allows them to not get their hopes up, and even not believe in good things happening to them. It's sad that someone should be forced to think like that because they were forced to grow up so fast. Being a teenager in itself is a crucial time for a person that any other stressors would just be too much. I remember getting extremely stressed out about a pimple on my face as a teenager, I couldn't imagine having to put food on the table at that time. When you're a young teenager your getting all of these hormones that cause you to feel all of these different things such as a pregnant women would feel. Could you imagine a pregnant women working all of those long hours, it's unhealthy. It is way too much responsibility for a young child to be adhering to.
When in poverty, you don't have as many choices as you would like about the way you live and there it's really sad that there is not more equality within the people. To me, if you're in poverty then the one's with the least sacrificing should be the children. They didn't ask to be there they did not ask to live that life they were put there so how can they be expected to be making up for what their parents have done. It's really sad that they would think that everything is depended on them. It's unhealthy to have that much responsibility that young, and the time of being young is something they will never get back.
